Opinion
OPINION: WHY THE NORTHERN IDENTITY AND UNITY GO BEYOND PERCEPTIONS.
By: A G Abubakar
The fact that the North has been in turmoil for the past two and a half decades is no news. Kids born in the dawn of the troubled region may not understand that the North used to be the most peaceful, stable, and very accommodating region of the country. Quiet a far cry from its current toxic ethno-religious and economic relations, driven largely by self-serving political interests and religious bigotry. Narratives that discounted the North’s geography, historical experiences, and the interconnectednes of the diverse groups that shaped its uniqueness.
The North may be going through rough time, but the potential to pull itself from the brink is in no doubt. Already, some soul searching and open engagements about the future are gaining traction across the board. The growing narrative is that the North’s destiny lies in its hands. It has to take the lead in finding the needed solutions. Though some engagements could, at times, be venomous, it is better than continuing to be in a state of denial. Other silver linings on the horizon include a growing tech-savvy and entrepreneurial base among the young generation and Arewa-centric Civil Society Organisations (CSOs) all rising to the occasion, especially the challenges in governance in the region.
How The Rot and Change of Perception May Have Set in
Years of bad governance with its concomitant socioeconomic challenges may have turned the peoples of the North on each other. And, that’s understandable. The logic is simple. Since the phenomenon of socioeconomic deprivations are invisible, the natural instinct is for victims to start interrogating the causes outside themselves. The range of “suspects” could include the next tribe, ethnic group, religion, and even political formation. In the circumstance circumstances, words are taken out of context, actions are misinterpreted, misunderstanding ensued, and conflicts get easily ignited. Nothing unites like a performing economy in a diverse setting.
A once upon a harmonious way of life, has given way to a vicious cycle of conflicts. Opportunists in the form of third parties, politicians, pastoralists, and preachers soon took advantage of the resultant cracks; widening them further. Where pastures and water are available in abundance, like in the Benue enclave, the conflicts could be largely triggered between herders and farmers over access, process, and potential farm infringement. Since farming and pastoralism, as occupations, are practiced by distinct groups, the strained relationship tends to easily acquire religious or tribal colourations, e.g, Tiv/Christian farmer vs. Fulani/Muslim herder. A purely economic calling is fought on the ethno-religious front.
It is this poorly managed economic relationship that has been fueling the crisis in such places as Plateau, Taraba, Adamawa and Borno, Niger, Kogi, Kaduna, and Nasarawa states. With the economic divisions firmly entrenched, politicians step in to form an electoral capital out of the people’s fears, apprehensions, and sentiments. They invoke the message of “us against them” or them” against us.” Words and expressions like, “we got to stand up for our rights,” “it’s our land, and we are ready to defend with the last drop of our lives,” “so vote for us to free yourself from domination,” soon rent the air.
Then comes the clerics, who interpret the fault lines (bad governance, economic deprivations) as divine punishment for transgression. They position themselves to redeem the situation by harvesting and promoting to widening their bases. Thus, fueling the divisions further. Bad governance, a man-made phenomenon, dressed as religious and/or ethnic pursuits constitutes the Northern challenge. A development that is likely to continue into the foreseeable future because of the increasingly poor capacity to manage the region’s diversity. This is as constituent parts of the region behave as if they existed mutually exclusive of each other in history, with requisite narratives in support of the perception.
The Common Historical Experiences and Antecedents
Fortunately, the challenges of unity are redeemable given the long-standing shared values and outlook shaped by both geography and historical experiences. History tells that the maze of relationships and unity among peoples of the North were predicated on three epochs and three (3) layers of common experience in descending order. They include:
the Colonial era (1900-1960), >pre-Colonial periods of the:
(i) Hausa City-states (1359-1808),
(ii) Kwararrafah Empire (14th Century-1840),
(iii) Kanem-Borno Empire (1376-1902),
Sokoto Caliphate, (1804-1904).
The empires of Borno, Kwararrafah, and the Hausa City-states existed side by side for centuries, though with fluid boundaries. The City-states were seven in number. They had no central authority and were united only by the Hausa language and some common cultural practices. The City-states comprised Daura, Katsina, Kano, Gobir, Rano, Zazzau (Zaria), and Biram (Hadeja) (Bala Usman, 2006).
Except for the Hausa City-states, too, the compositions of the Kwararrafah, Kanem-Borno, the Sokoto Caliphate, and the Colonial North were very diverse in terms of ethnicity and culture. The City-states of the time cover today’s Hausa land. The loosely organised Kwararrafah comprised present day’s ethnic nationalities like Tiv, Idoma, Igala, Nupe, Gbagi (Gwari), Babur, Bolewa, Jarawa, Jukun, Angas, Zuru, Atyyap, Zuru, (Dakkarawa) and many more.
The fact of occupying the same geographic space was more or less a “fait accompli” in making the diverse groups to deal with each other in matters of both peace and conflicts. A sort of, for better or for worse. During times of peace, they exchanged goods and services (trading), just as conflicts were rife as well. Geography could therefore be considered as providing the first and also natural context for a common experience among the diverse Northern groups. The Jukuns and their allies, for instance, traded with the Zazzau, Kano, and Katsina for a long time. They equally waged wars of supremacy against each other. According to the Kano Chronicle, the Jukuns at certain periods controlled Kano’s surroundings. Those interactions certainly entailed subtle exchange of cultures and traditions. The Jukun influences are still visible in some Karaye communities of Kano. According to Fremantle, J.M, a historian on Kwararrafah, the entity’s influence also extended to such places as Kano, Katsina, Borno, the lands of Igala, Idoma, Igbira and others, in between.
Within the Kwararrafah itself, groups like Nupe and Igala shared some historical ties through an Igala prince, Tsoede, who was believed to have founded the “original” Nupe kingdom. This was, as the Nupe interacted (war and peace) with the Katsinawa to the North. The Nupe also was a defining fortress for the North to the West, where it created a buffer zone that extended as far as Offa. Nupe was actually destabilised and, on occasions, sacked Offa between 1448 and 1567. Today a Fulani dynasty is one of KinNupe ruling families.
The Igala did a similar job to the South where they fortified northern fringes of Igbo land with North. They networked with their neighbouring Idoma cousins to the north-east, up to the Tiv, Gbagi, and Jukun enclaves. The legendary Queen Amina (1533-1610) of Zazzau (Zaria) died and was buried in Okpachala Ogbagba, a community near IdahIgala land after a failed expedition.
The Jukun group had a close, though at times, checkered relationships with inhabitants of the northeast. It engaged in a couple of wars with Kanem Borno, just as both of them engaged other parts of the Hausaland at different times. It was like a merry-go-round in an interdependence relationship during which person-to-person as well as commercial interactions ensued. At no time, therefore, did the groups – majority or minority – operate exclusive of one another.
The historical relationships continued until the arrival of Dan Fodio, the Fulani Islamic reformer on the scene. A part of the second layer of regional experience. He was able to bring a huge cross section of the North under his Islamic Caliphate called the Sokoto Caliphate. About thirteen flag bearers of the Caliphate were appointed across the region to propagate and safeguard the theocratic message of “purifying” the practice of Islam as a way of life. This experience, to a large extent, has had an impact in shaping the Northern muslim outlook, irrespective of ethnic or cultural backgrounds.
Then came the third wave; the colonialists who declared the region a British Protectorate. They went on to revoke the charter of the Royal Niger Company and formally imposed the British rule. That was in 1900 and it marked the formal beginning of the colonial period in Northern Nigeria. The administration dislodged the Sokoto Caliphate in1903. Thereafter, Western education was introduced along with Christianity, largely in the non-Muslim areas of the region. Like in the case of Islam, the new phenomena (western education and Christianity), added another layer of common values over the North; that impacted the lives, relationships and worldview of the region as well. Call it modernity.
The post-Colonial era saw the Sardauna, Ahmadu Bello, at the helm of affairs as the premier of defunct Northern Nigeria. He was able to use the experience of the Colonial Administration (extension of the third wave) to galvanise and unite the region into a cohesive entity.
Using an all-inclusive team and appropriate policy frameworks, based on the principles of one North, one people, and one destiny.
The Northern government’s cabinet composition and its holistic development policy remain a model to date. The engine room of the Administration of the Time included David Lot, Peter Achimugu, G.U.Ohikere, Hassan Lemu, Michael Audu Buba, Dr. R.A.B.Dikko, Aliyu Obaje, Rwang Pam, Jolly Tanko Yusuf, Audu Obekpa, Abdulrahaman Okene, Tanko Kuta, Muhammad Ribaɗu, Isa Koto, Sunday Awoniyi, Ibrahim Biu, Sir Kashim Ibrahim, Ahmed Talib, Aliyu Makaman Bida, J.A. Aberigbe, Ahmed Talib, Bukar Shuaib, Mahmud Jega, Yahaya Gusau, Isa Kaita, Patrick Dokotri, Ahman Pategi, etc. It was also alleged that the Sardauna was fond of Chukwuma Nzegwu, fondly referred to as Major Kaduna. The names of the Sardauna’s team are indicative of both ethnic and religious backgrounds. For sure inclusiveness couldn’t look any better!
The development process was very equitable and strategic. Capital projects were distributed across the region. There was no attempt to skew infrastructure to individual’s enclaves. Some of the region’s infrastructure at the time include, College of Agriculture, Kabba, Secondary Schools in Dekina, Bida, Keffi, Okene. A University College (now ABU, Zaria) and Agricultural Research Centre, both in Zaria and also a Veterinary School Vom, Jos. Forest Reserves and Plantations were established in Mokwa, Falgore, and other places, including the first irrigation scheme in the North at Yau, in the Chad Basin region of Born. Non was sited in Rabah, Sardauna’s home town. Neither also went to Gusau, Kaita, or Jega, the place of origin of some of his right-hand officers.
The efficacy of mutual accommodation and tolerance on the North’s unity had been profound, especially in the realm of inter-ethnic relations. The Tiv and Fulani fable of “Mun ci” (we have eaten, the cow you left in our care), the Kanuri and Fulani are joke-mate, too. So are the Gobirawa and Yoruba, the Babur and Bolewa/Karaikarai, Kanawa and Zagizagi, etc, all signifying historical cordiallity
Some Of The Contemporary Realities
History tells that many famous families across the North were actually guests at some point, and they became fully integrated into their hosts’ communities without qualms. Sometimes of the famous settler-to-indegines families include the Yakasais, Abachas, Shinkafis, Bawa Garbas, Chanchangis, Tofas, Musa ‘Yar aduas, etc
The Shinkafi brothers, Umaru and Mamuda, from Gashua, in today’s Yobe State, were Marafan Sokoto and Zamfara State governor, respectively.
H.E. former state governor Shekarau, allegedly has links with the North East enclave. He became a governor in the Kano state and currently a Sardaunan, Kano.
The Wazirin Katsina, Ibrahim Ida’s family is believed to be of Igala extraction, allegedly too. He now holds sway in Katsina royal palace.
Elder statesman, Tanko Yakasai, Jukun has represented Kano in Federal Legislature, Executive Council, and now a respected elder in Kano.
The Bashir Tofas and the Abachas are, for instance, the first exclusively-Hausa-speaking generations of their Kanuri families in Kano. Their parents came to Kano as Kanuri merchants. Hon. Shehu Bawa Garba that represented Kaduna North in the State House of Assembly is Bura from Garkiɗa, Adamawa, while the scions of Ahmadu Chanchangi who are now power brokers in Kaduna are of Jukun origin from Taraba. Currently, one Hon. Nelson Chukwu Cyprian Len represents Nguroje Constituency in Taraba State House of Assembly. His story is similar to that of Tudun-Wada-born Comrade Shehu Sani, who became a Senator representing Kaduna North between 2015 and 2019, belonging to one of the tribes of Niger State. In 1961, Ibrahim Imam of Borno Youth Movement (BYM) contested and won an election to represent Tiv District in the defunct Northern House of Assembly.
Today, the ruling dynasty in Lafiya, Nasarawa state is Kanuri, just as one of the three or so families in Zazzau remains Kanuri too. Ja’afaru ɗan Ishaku was the 26th Emir of Zazzau and the 9th in the Kanuri dynasty.
The Bachama (Bwatiye) people of Adamawa (North East) are believed to come from Gobir (North West) before settling at the banks of river Benue. A mutual exchange of goodwill still thrives between the two groups especially during respective traditional leadership installations. Their immediate neighbours in Borno especially the Babur and Bura share a lot of traditions with the Jukun and Gbagi peoples. The royal totem or insignia of Crocodile is held in reverence in the palaces of Aku Uka of Wukari and Emir of Biu. This is regardless of the fact that the Biu ruling dynasty is believed to be of Kanuri and Mandara origin. The Gbagi that shares boundaries with parts of Kebbi share the tradition of carrying load on the shoulder instead of head with the Babur of the North East. Both have culinary culture that includes mbuli and machikle (a fermented and unfermented food leftover) that are at times consumed with garden eggs.
Musa ‘Yar Adu’a Snr (1912) the father of Shehu and Umar was of Kanuri extraction as well. His mother a Katsina princess was married to a Kanuri Islamic scholar. That was during the reign of Muhammad Dikko, 1906 to 1944. Umaru ended as a president of the Federal Republic.
With all the historical mix and antecedents on how the Northern region and its peoples evolved as an entity, the narrative to effect that it never was a distinct sociocultural mosaic or tapestry, might just be a self-serving one. For sure, the Northern unity may not be a perfect entity, but then, no unity is. Nations and regions remain work in progress. The trouble with the region has to do with decades of mismanagement and poor sense of proportion on the part of successive leaderships.
Literally, bad governance, that has created a high sense of disaffection, disillusionment and disharmony across the region. Nothing disunite people like deprivations, and Northerners are grappling with this phenomenon more than ever before. It’s a region simply not working. Things have to change. Fortunately, this reality is gaining traction across the the North despite the call from some quarters that it needs to be dismembered, which is a jaundiced perception.
Keeping It Together Is Still The Way To Go
Truth was, should the North get dismembered, every successor component part shall have the old North in it. The lines demarcation may seem clear in the head but the reality shall be the opposite. Let the factors that are causing the ill feelings, which are basically two, be addressed. They are; justice and equity across ethno-religious divide and the adoption of a general sense of proportion in governance at all levels.
The followership too needs to be better informed. Ignorance plays a huge part in the challenges across the North. The task may be onerous but it is feasible. The Northern family is a by-product both geopolitical and historical realities than myths. Let the North shall rise again.
A.G.Abubakar agbarewa@gmail.com
Opinion
A Malicious Fabrication Dressed As Analysis: The Defamation Of Justice John Tsoho And Justice Peter Lifu
By Danjuma Lamido
Mr Chidi Odinkalu’s write up is not journalism. It is not analysis. It is not even credible criticism but modus of mob/ touting, orchestrated to sway the hoi polloi and his myrmidons.
It is a scurrilous, tendentious, and intellectually bankrupt concoction, designed to assassinate character, desecrate the judiciary, and intimidate independent cum unbiased judges into submission to political hysteria.
It deserves not applause, but categorical repudiation, with hereinafter analytical reasoning:
- THE PREMISE IS PREPOSTEROUS AND PROFOUNDLY IGNORANT
Mr Chidi Odinkalu, begins with a fundamental misapprehension of judicial administration, and proceeds to build an edifice of calumny/ his shangri-la
Case assignment is an administrative function, exercised under established rules, workload considerations, expertise, availability, and the exigencies of the division.
To transmogrify routine administrative discretion into a conspiracy is the hallmark of a mind intoxicated by paranoia and multi faceted mischief.
The insinuation that assignment equals predetermination is an insult to every judge who has ever decided a case on its merits. It is an insult to the intelligence of Nigerians. It suggests that judges are automatons, incapable of independent reasoning, and that judgments are dictated rather than reasoned.
That is false. That is libellous. That is ludicrous.
- THERE IS NO CLOSED LIST, ONLY A CLOSED MIND
The fanciful invention of a “closed list of acolytes” and a “coven of political hitmen” reveals more about the Mr Chidi Odinkalu than about the court.
Where is the evidence? Where is the document? Where is the witness? Where is the proof?
There is none. There is only innuendo, embellishment, and the reckless deployment of sinister adjectives to mask an embarrassing absence of facts.
To label cerebral honourable judicial officers as acolytes, surrogates, and hitmen is not criticism. It is character assassination of the most despicable kind. It is an attempt to delegitimise judgments simply because they are unfavourable to a preferred political faction.
Disagreement with a judgment is legitimate. Demonisation of the judge is despicable.
- JUDICIAL DECISIONS ARE JURISPRUDENCE, BUT NOT JOBBERY AS CAPTURED IN THE WORLD OF MR CHIDI ODINKALU
The catalogue of decisions attributed to Justice Lifu is presented as though deciding a case is itself a crime.
It is not.
A judge is appointed to decide. A judge is bound to interpret the law, evaluate evidence, and pronounce judgment, even when that judgment displeases powerful politicians and their vociferous apologists, and in recognition of the immutable facts- that no two cases are identical.
To declare a leadership illegal, to nullify an emergence, or to invalidate a nomination is not rascality. It is adjudication. If a party believes a decision is wrong, the law provides a remedy: appeal. It does not provide a licence for public lynching on social media (court of public opinion).
The author conveniently ignores the existence of appellate remedies, because appellate remedies require legal argument. Social media calumny requires only vitriol.
Furthermore, the claim that Justice Lifu disregarded the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court is a gross/ deliberate distortion of facts. Judicial hierarchy is a matter for appellate courts to determine, through reasoned judgments, not for commentators to declare through hashtags. If any error occurred, it will be corrected on appeal, as the system contemplates. It will not be corrected by mob intimidation.
- THE ATTACK ON CHIEF JUDGE TSOHO IS AN ATTACK ON THE INSTITUTION ITSELF
Chief Judge John Terhemba Tsoho is a jurist of considerable learning, experience, and unimpeachable integrity. To accuse him of collusion, corruption, and servicing an unnamed patron, without a shred of verifiable evidence, is an act of unmitigated recklessness.
It is easy to allege a patron. It is easy to whisper about political wind. It is cowardly to do so without naming, proving, or substantiating anything.
What the author calls a pattern is, in reality, a pattern of his own prejudice cum imagination: every decision against his favoured party is corrupt, every judge who rules against them is compromised, and every administrator who assigns the case is a conspirator.
That is not the language of justice. That is the language of entitlement. It is the language of those who believe the court exists to validate their political ambitions, rather than to uphold the law.
It unequivocal self evident that this Mr Chidi Odinkalu’s venomous virtupuration and vilification of most revered profession that raised him to prominence and relevance, is not only derisory and cretinous but an inane, asinine, fatuous and preposterous display of obtuse nescience.
Let the courts decide cases. Let appellate courts correct errors. Let commentators learn restraint. And let the masquerade of malicious falsehood be unmasked for what it truly is: -a disgraceful assault on the rule of law.
Opinion
OPINIONImams and Islamic Scholars in Partisan Politics and the Weight of Religious Conviction.
.
By: A G Abubakar
It was the late Sardauna, Ahmadu Bello, who told Nnamdi Azikiwe, fondly called Zik, that they should understand their differences rather than forget them. That was in reaction to Zik’s call on the Sardauna to forget their differences in order to move the then nascent Federal Republic of Nigeria forward.
The message in Sardauna’s reply was that differences are what naturally define and distinguish one society or group from another. These differences may be rooted in faith, culture, or tradition. They constitute the sociological makeup of a people and are often difficult to abandon or merge into one another. Understanding one another makes it easier to identify common ground and leverage it to build a strong, virile and united entity.
More than half a century later, Nigerian society has yet to achieve even an adequate understanding among its diverse constituent groups, let alone forget their differences. The lesson here is that, as Imams plunge into the murky waters of Western liberal democracy, they should be mindful of the burden of understanding differences and the challenge of forgetting them.
There is practically nothing that says Imams should not participate in politics, constitutionally or otherwise. However, because of the demands of democracy, which have a high probability of clashing with their Islamic values, many have stayed away from partisanship. That attitude seems to have changed. Open declarations of political support, campaigns to secure party tickets, and the use of pulpits to advance partisan interests have increasingly come to define the relationship between Muslim clerics in Northern Nigeria and partisan politics.
Many clerics have become cheerleaders for political figures, often openly declaring their partisan support for politicians and political parties, sometimes with reckless abandon. In return for such endorsements, political actors and governments have extended assorted forms of patronage to them. Cash donations running into millions of naira, as witnessed in Jos; privileged access to Aso Rock; bulk allocations of palliatives; and sponsorship of Hajj pilgrimages illustrate some of the material benefits associated with political loyalty.
Some have gone a step further by abandoning the pulpit for the political arena and throwing their hats into the ring. They are no longer content with counselling their followers on such issues as piety, civic responsibilities, and “voting wisely.” They want to be voted into political office, too. They have that inalienable right.
The Nigerian Constitution enshrines this right. Sections 65 and 66, 106 and 107, 131 and 137, and 177 and 182 of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (as amended) prescribe the qualifications and disqualifications for membership of the National Assembly and State Houses of Assembly, as well as for the offices of governor and president, respectively. These provisions do not discriminate on the basis of faith.
Why single out Imams for scrutiny for seeking elective positions? Or generally for becoming partisan? Why are their counterparts, the pastors, not subjected to the same scrutiny? The answers are simple: leadership contexts and principles differ, sometimes so fundamentally that it takes uncommon willpower to suppress and reconcile one’s intrinsic beliefs with the dictates of Western liberal democracy. The Islamic political system and democratic practice may share a common vision of liberty (‘yanci) and justice (adalci), but they differ in their fundamental political processes and jurisprudence.
Most clerics have been schooled in the Islamic system of governance—the Sharia. Divesting themselves of deeply ingrained Islamic political convictions while discharging their democratic responsibilities may not be the easiest task.
A Christian cleric participating in democratic politics may arguably be seen as making a homecoming because of the historical relationship between the Church and the state. Christianity emerged in the eastern Mediterranean, within a world shaped by Jewish religious traditions and Greco-Roman civilisation.
As it spread across Europe, it encountered societies whose cultural and religious identities had already been shaped by Greek, Roman, Germanic, Celtic, and other pre-Christian traditions. Its expansion did not simply erase everything that preceded it. Rather, the encounter between Christianity and these traditions produced a complex process of religious transformation and cultural adaptation.
On the other hand, Christianity has also played a significant role in shaping Western political thought, particularly through Christian ideas and values. It all started when the Church found itself filling the political vacuum following the collapse of the Western Roman Empire. The Church was inadvertently drawn into playing both secular political and spiritual roles at the same time. That was between 500 and 1000 AD. In the second era, between 1000 and 1300 AD, kings and the Church shared leadership. It was during this period that the former claimed the “divine right” to rule.
After centuries of turmoil within the Church and the monarchy, the two institutions were separated, ushering in an era of secular democracy and the rule of law. This process, particularly from 1789 onwards, was preceded by a long period during which the Church and the state mutually shaped each other in many respects. For instance the Church influenced the democratic concepts of equality before God (Law); freedom of conscience; separating religious and political authority (things of Caesar and things of God); universal suffrage (Benedictine orders); and institutional unconditional care for the vulnerable (agape), etc.
The theological and jurisprudential relationship between Islam and democracy has a different historical background. Islam developed a political and legal tradition in which religious and political authority were historically interconnected, a relationship that has continued to influence Muslim societies to this day. The process of Islamic governance started with the early Muslim community under the Prophet Muhammad (SAW). He was guided by wah’y (devine inspiration), an aspect of which gave rise to the Constitution of Medina (622 AD). The subsequent institution of the caliphate after his death, developed an Islamic jurisprudence, and traditions concerning political leadership, justice, consultation (shura), allegiance (bay’ah), and public responsibility, based on the Prophet’s teachings.
In classical Islamic jurisprudence, political authority is generally understood to be subject to divine law and moral obligations derived from Islamic sources. In liberal democracy, political authority is ordinarily constituted and limited by a constitutional order grounded in popular sovereignty, individual rights, and the rule of law. These principles can conflict, particularly where interpretations of religious law differ from constitutional guarantees of individual liberty, religious equality, or popular legislative authority. The two systems, however, overlap in such areas as justice, accountability, consultation, and the welfare of society.
The dilemma facing an Imam who enters democratic politics is the challenge of reconciling his background with the demands of the Western democratic system within which he must operate. He knows that the sources of Islamic jurisprudence are generally identified as the Qur’an and Sunnah, with ijma’ (juristic consensus) and qiyas (analogical reasoning) among the principal methods recognised in Islam. This contrasts with democracy, where people and institutions formulate laws.
He also understands that political leadership is not merely an electoral contest between individuals seeking popularity. Rather, it is guided by certain qualifications, including maturity, soundness of mind, sufficient religious knowledge for the responsibilities of leadership, justice or uprightness, competence, and the ability to discharge the functions of governance. Some classical jurists also prescribed conditions such as male sex, lineage (Shi’a Imamate), among others, though with certain nuances.
The underlying principle, however, is significant: leadership is conceived as a trust and responsibility, not merely a badge of honour to be won. The Qur’anic concept of amanah—trust—therefore has profound implications for political leadership. The leader is not simply accountable to voters. He is ultimately accountable to God. That theological dimension distinguishes Islamic political ethics from the secular constitutional conception of political authority, where sovereignty, authority, and legitimacy rest with the people.
The Nigerian secular Constitution, for example, begins with the words: “We the people of the Federal Republic of Nigeria…” It establishes a constitutional order in which governmental authority is exercised through institutions created by the Constitution. In Islamic political theology, however, ultimate sovereignty belongs to Allah. The Qur’an states:
“The command is for none but Allah.” Qur’an 12:40.
Muslim scholars have interpreted the political implications of such verses differently. Some Islamist thinkers have used the concept of hakimiyyah,divine sovereignty,to argue that legislation cannot legitimately contradict divine law. Others have argued that democracy can be reconciled with Islam if it is understood as a mechanism for consultation, accountability, and the peaceful selection of rulers rather than as an assertion that human beings possess unlimited authority to legislate against God’s commands.
Beyond the religious injunctions is the more difficult question of conscience and the burden of knowing. A cleric who enters politics must operate within a constitutional system whose laws, institutions, and political culture may not always correspond perfectly with his understanding of Islamic jurisprudence.
A politician may have to negotiate with individuals whose lifestyles, beliefs, or political positions he strongly disagrees with. He may have to defend constitutional rights for people whose choices he personally considers morally wrong. He may have to work with political parties whose internal practices and the character of some of their members are far removed from his religious ideals.
One of the most significant areas of potential tension is the meaning of freedom. Liberal democracy protects freedom of expression, association, religion, and political participation. These freedoms extend to citizens with whom the cleric may profoundly disagree. A democracy does not merely protect popular or respectable opinions. It also protects unpopular opinions, minority viewpoints, and, within constitutional limits, conduct that sections of society may consider offensive or immoral.
Other dilemmas include: is political freedom absolute?
Can citizens publicly criticise religion?
Should people be permitted to advocate lifestyles that a cleric regards as sinful?
Can a Muslim politician defend the constitutional rights of people whose personal conduct violates his religious convictions?
What about theft, inheritance, adultery, murder, and treason, among other matters?
A typical Nigerian Muslim cleric may have been exposed to three or more historically related theological models of political leadership and governance. The first is based on the Constitution of Medina, promulgated by the Prophet to establish a harmonious community. The second is the Pact of Umar, associated with Caliph Umar, the second of the four Rightly Guided Caliphs. It essentially structured society along the lines of the ruling class/religion and the ruled (Dhimmis), subject to specified conditions and obligations.
The third is the Millet (Milla) system, which was used during the Ottoman period. Under this system, leadership and control were devolved to accommodate distinct social and religious formations, which remained answerable to the Caliph. These three or more models are not mutually exclusive, as they evolved as part of the Sharia state system.
Challenges arise when the setting is diverse, with Muslim and non-Muslim populations being almost equal, and governance is based on Western liberal democracy, as is currently the case in Nigeria. Muslim scholars venturing into politics with a mindset shaped by any of the three systems may find it highly challenging, and delicate to navigate.
Perhaps that is why three groups have emerged among the clerics on this matter. The first comprises those who choose to distance themselves from democratic politics. The second encourages participation as a means of minimising potential harm to Muslims (maslahah and wasilah). The third comprises those who consider participation in democratic governance unacceptable and will stop at nothing to oppose it, including the use of violence. They argue that sovereignty belongs to God (hakimiyyah) and that human-made legislation (democracy) inherently contradicts divine law (Sharia).
Those who choose to participate in the democratic dispensation on a partisan basis belong to the second category, but they carry the burden of understanding the other dispensations and the implications of their decisions. To begin with, they must have a high degree of intellectual clarity about the two systems: they must understand their obligations under Sharia, understand constitutional democracy, and know where the two converge and where they diverge.
They must also acknowledge that the ulama cannot absolve themselves of responsibility for some of the persistent challenges confronting the North in particular and the nation at large. Their sectarianisn, complicity, internal divisions, or failure to provide the necessary moral and intellectual leadership may have, in no small measure, contributed to the problems the society faces. The same challenges a section of them is trying to address through full participation in partisan politics.
It is also obvious that they need to know, as a matter of fact, that once elected to public office in Nigeria, their oath is to the Constitution and the people, not to a personal clerical constituency. This is particularly important as they deal with issues such as political legitimacy under non-Islamic jurisprudence; legislation by democratic institutions in relation to divine injunctions; and political and moral accountability under Islam and democracy, among others.
The turban can enter the ballot box. It can even enter the Government House or the National Assembly. But once inside, it must confront the full demands of constitutional democracy. That is where clerical politics will ultimately be tested: what to forget, what to understand, and what to hold on to, without compounding the challengeson the ground. .
It will take uncommon patriotism to rise above Zik’s “let’s forget our differences” and Sardauna’s “let’s understand our differences” to embrace and defend a system that challenges the very foundations of one’s theological convictions. It is no small undertaking. Wishing the clerics well, provided their motivations are genuinely driven by the interests of the people and a sense of accountability to the Almighty.
A. G. Abubakar
agbarewa@gmail.com
Opinion
Women and the Nobel peace prize
BY VICTORIA NGOZI IKEANO
victoriangozii@gmail.com 08033077519
For the second consecutive year women have won the Nobel Peace Prize. Altogether 69 women have since its inception in 1901 won the Nobel Prize which is in five categories, namely, Physics, Chemistry, Medicine, Literature and Economics. Understandably, there are more male laureates than female. However, this columnist is more interested in the female laureates and more specifically in women winners of the Nobel prize for peace. I consider the peace prize as the most important of all five types of prizes because peace is the fulcrum for order and harmony from which ensue undisturbed development in joyous activity that makes for upwards progress and leads to real happiness.
Let us delve into some statistics about the Nobel Prize for peace as it relates to women. Overall, 21 females have been awarded this particular prize. The very first woman to win the peace prize was Bertha von Suttner, also described as the first Austrian Laureate, that is, the first female from Austria to be awarded a Nobel Prize. Bertha von Suttner was given the prize in 1905 “for her influential anti-war activism, her leadership in international peace movement and her authoring the famous pacifist novel, ‘Lay down your arms”’. Among other women Nobel peace prize winners are, Mother Teresa, Malala Yousafzai and Narges Mohammadi. Mother Teresa, a nun clinched the prize in 1979, “ for her work for bringing help to suffering humanity”, According to the awarding body this involves, “building homes for orphans, nursing homes for lepers and hospices for the terminally ill” in Calcutta, India through founding a new sisterhood, Missionaries for Charity.
Malala Yousafzai, at just age 17 (the youngest laureate) was awarded the Nobel peace prize in 2014 alongside Kailash Sayarthi (as joint winners), “for their struggle against the suppression of children and young people and for the right of all children to education”. Specifically, Malala, a Pakistani was honoured “for her fight for every child to receive education”. In 2012 she literally cheated death when she was shot in the head in a school bus, thereafter fleeing to England to live in exile. She was named among the ‘100 most influential people’ by Time magazine in 2013. “On her 16th birthday she spoke in the United Nations. In her speech Malala called for equal right to education for girls all over the world and became a symbol of this cause”.
With the latest award to South African Navi Pillay, there are now three female African Nobel peace laureates; the others being Wangari Maathai of Kenya (2004) and Ellen Johnson Sirleaf. Sirleaf was joint winners with Leymah Gbowee and Tawakkoi Karman for “for their non violent struggle for the safety of women and for women’s rights to full participation in peace-building work”. In particular Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, a former Liberian president is described as Africa’s first female democratically elected head of state that “came to power in 2005, creating peace and economic progress in the country. She strengthened women’s rights, expanded freedom of speech and became an example for other African leaders”. On her part, Wangari Maathai clinched it “for her contribution to sustainable development, democracy and peace via the Green Belt Movement”.
Narges Mohammadi won it in 2023 for fighting the oppression of women and promoting human rights in Iran. She is said to have been arrested 13 times, sentenced to 31 years in prison with 154 lashes between 1998 and 2023. She was named Nobel peace prize winner whilst still in prison. Also, Venezuela opposition leader Maria Corina Machado won it last year, 2025. Machado had to be smuggled out of Venezuela with help of United States to be able to receive her prize because of restrictions placed on her by her home government. The latest female Nobel peace prize winner (2026) is Navi Pillay, a former South African High Court Judge who also served as head of the United Nations Human Rights court. She was so honoured for “being instrumental in ensuring war crimes against humanity and genocide are prosecuted”.
All 21 female Nobel Peace winners were mostly activists in one way or other. Their activities are exemplary, worthy of emulation and praise. They were brought to limelight through exposure by the international media which in turn helped propel them to recognition. Still, efforts of all the Nobel laureates, male and female as well as others working externally in public domains in quest for global peace is like a drop in the ocean. One area that can contribute maximally to world peace is the HOME. The home from where all of us take the first steps into the larger society, the outside world, is the very first place to nurture peaceful citizens in whom is rooted peaceful disposition in all its ramifications. Here, the woman holds sway, here is her high office. She has been imbued by the Creator with the ability to influence every fruit of her womb through high guidance as a guide, guardian and teacher. Unfortunately, we women have trampled and neglected the gifts bestowed on us by the Almighty in pursuit of worldly recognitions; we have neglected the home, turned away from our sacred callings, chasing vainglorious sham instead. The result is that we have through our wayward living, unworthy of genuine womanhood, masked by false piety literally stretched our hands to the under-world, dark regions and begetting human beings who are no more than agents of darkness, tormenting everyone with their evil deeds everywhere and peace is eluding mankind. We women bear the greater blame for this sad state of affairs!
-
Uncategorized6 years agoFG, states urged to harness flooding for ranching, others with technology – Agbaje
-
Headlines11 years agoBreaking: EFCC seals Borno House of Assembly, as Hon members take to their heels
-
News12 years agoNigeria Security Operatives Stage Manhunt For Homosexual Perpetrator
-
News10 years agoHow 21-year-old Girl fled community over accusation of lesbianism
-
News11 years agoYobe Gov Moves Against Deputy
-
Opinion8 years ago7 signs she has friend zoned you
-
Technology5 years ago
Online job placement company headhunts women
-
Headlines11 years agoBorno Dep Gov Abducts Another Church Leader
